Cargo Theft was Top Supply Chain Risk in 2015

Mar 28, 2016MH&L Staff

What is in this article?:

• Cargo Theft was Top Supply Chain Risk in 2015
• Sources of Security Issues

Damages caused by cargo theft amounted to $22.6 billion in 2015.

Last year supply chains across the world faced a number of challenges. One of the largest issues was damages caused by cargo theft, an amount estimated at $22.6 billion, according to BSI’s Supply Chain Risk Exposure Evaluation Network.

Other issues included:

• Increased number of terrorism incidents which contributed to billions of dollars in losses to global shipping companies.
• An influx of migrants in Europe affected supply chain integrity across the continent.
• Economic downturns in Argentina, Brazil, and China put pressure on the global supply chain as did political transparency that drove social unrest in Africa and Central America.
• Extreme weather events, including many attributed to the El Nino phenomenon, caused supply chain disruptions and threatened business continuity in multiple regions.
• There were also several industries that were plagued by poor enforcement of labor regulations, allowing for significant rates of child or forced labor in Argentina and India, among other nations.

"Companies are facing an increasingly wide range of challenges to their supply chain, from human rights issues to acts of violent theft and natural disasters,” explains Jim Yarbrough, global intelligence program manager at BSI. Formed in 1901, BSI was the world's first National Standards Body and a founding member of the International Organization for Standardization (ISO).

"Such complexity creates extreme levels of risk for organizations, both directly affecting the bottom line but perhaps more seriously, hidden threats to the supply chain which, if ignored, could do serious harm to a company's hard-earned reputation," Yarbrough adds.

Sources of Security Issues

Looking more closely at the nearly $23 billion that was lost due to cargo theft worldwide in 2015 from a variety of supply chain threats, the risk was predominantly driven by security concerns. South Africa has seen a 30% increase in cargo truck hijackings over the last year, with thieves using high levels of violence and switching from targeting only high value goods to also targeting lower value items.

Daring vehicle shipment thefts have become increasingly commonplace in China, with a recent series of in-transit vehicle thefts occurring along the busy G45 highway. More sophisticated attacks were observed in India throughout 2015, where criminal gangs masterminded new techniques to steal goods without breaking customs seals in order to avoid detection – a major risk for companies participating in international supply chain security programs.

In Europe, disruptions in trade caused by the ISIS terrorist group clearly highlighted the link between terrorism and the supply chain. Border controls in France following the November attacks in Paris are estimated to have cost the Belgian shipping industry $3.5 million. Terrorist-linked smuggling rings were also identified to be colluding between Spain and the Middle East, the groups illegally transporting shipments of stolen electronics, drugs, weapons and other contraband. Elsewhere, the Jordanian trucking industry suffered $754 million in lost revenue since conflict began in the Middle East in 2011.

Other Risk Factors

In addition to theft, business continuity-related threats such as extreme weather events and political and social unrest, led to significant losses for individual companies and national economies last year. 2015's top five natural disasters caused a collective $33 billion of damage to businesses. In 2016, BSI has identified emerging health crises, such as the Zika virus, could also pose a significant threat to the global supply chain and may lead to work stoppages and protests similar to the supply chain disruptions seen in conjunction with the Ebola epidemic.

Labor unrest and factory strikes have also caused considerable financial damage across the world. Factory strikes in China increased by 58%  from the previous year due to pay disputes, as factory owners struggled to pay workers due to a slowing economy, leading to protests. The withholding of wages was cited as a major cause in 75% of protests and generated losses of up to $27 million in the footwear industry. Labor unrest is likely to continue in China in 2016, regardless of whether the economy improves.

Numerous cases of child and forced labor were exposed in 2015, highlighting the need for visibility into corporate supply chain to mitigate the risk of human rights abuses. Nearly 80% of Argentina's textile industry was found to be sourcing from unregulated facilities, where forced, child labor and poor working conditions are common. BSI also noted an increase in the risk of child labor use in India due to the existence of loopholes in labor reforms approved in 2015.  In response to these and other recent concerns, European countries and the United States last year moved to pass laws mandating reporting on corporate social responsibility issues in corporate supply chains.

The biggest threats to the global supply chain in 2016 include:

1.  Global cargo theft cost estimated to grow by a further $1 billion in 2016. Increased concerns in China, Germany, India, Mexico, South Africa, and United States

2.  Continued tensions in South China Sea predicted to lead to further protests and disruptions

3. On-going conflict in Syria will continue to impact supply chains. The migrant crisis will continue to lead to port disruptions. European Union/Schengen border controls are predicted to have far-reaching impact.

4.  As we’ve already seen this year in Brussels, Belgium, ISIS is predicted to remain a significant threat to disrupt supply chains

5.  Labor unrest in China is predicted to persist, as a slowdown in the Chinese economy continues and more jobs move to neighboring countries.

6. Weather disruptions e.g. La Nina phenomenon

7.  Global health crises e.g. Zika and Ebola.